10 Underrated Taylor Swift Songs That Deserve Way More Love – How Many Are on YOUR Playlist?
Swifties, we need to talk. Taylor Swift’s catalog is a treasure chest of musical gems, and not all of them get the attention they deserve. Sure, “Shake It Off” and “Anti-Hero” dominate the airwaves, but what about the deep cuts? You know, those tracks that only real Swifties rave about? Let’s dive into some of the most underrated Taylor Swift songs that should have been bigger hits. Trust me, you’re going to want to revisit these ASAP.
#1: “All You Had To Do Was Stay” (1989) – Why Does This Always Get Overlooked?
Let’s start with this bop from 1989. Why did we all sleep on this? It’s got a killer hook, the perfect pop beat, and those iconic Swift bridge lyrics that make you want to scream-sing in the car. The lyrics hit you right in the feels: “All you had to do was stay / Had me in the palm of your hand.” And yet, this gem was never released as a single. Imagine if this song had a music video? It would’ve broken records.
#2: “I Think He Knows” (Lover) – It’s The Feel-Good Song You Didn’t Know You Needed
Admit it—Lover is full of shiny, bubblegum pop hits, but “I Think He Knows” is that subtle feel-good track that just makes you want to dance. It’s like a mini serotonin boost, wrapped in a three-minute track. The guitar riff? Infectious. The playful lyrics? So classic Taylor. So why did it get overshadowed by songs like “You Need to Calm Down”? It’s time we give it the spotlight it deserves.
#3: “Mad Woman” (Folklore) – Who Doesn’t Love a Little Revenge Anthem?
Okay, Folklore stans, listen up. You know “Mad Woman” is pure lyrical genius, right? The song perfectly captures that slow-burning anger and frustration we’ve all felt at some point. But despite its brilliance, it didn’t get its time to shine during The Eras Tour—well, except for that surprise performance that had us all crying. It’s raw, it’s real, and it’s the kind of song that’ll haunt you long after it ends. How this wasn’t a single still baffles us.
#4: “Clean” (1989) – The Best Taylor Swift Song to Cry To?
Are you even a true Swiftie if “Clean” hasn’t made you weep at least once? It’s a masterpiece of emotional clarity. With lyrics like “The drought was the very worst / When the flowers that we’d grown together died of thirst,” it’s Taylor at her most poetic. And while “Blank Space” and “Style” stole the spotlight from 1989, “Clean” is the one that lingers with you long after the album ends. It’s not just a song; it’s therapy.
#5: “The Way I Loved You” (Fearless) – Bring Back the Drama!
Remember the chaos of teenage love? The screaming, the passion, the rollercoaster of emotions? That’s exactly what “The Way I Loved You” captures. This track from Fearless perfectly balances nostalgia with just the right amount of drama. Sure, we love the reimagined Fearless (Taylor’s Version), but how come we’re not talking about this track enough? It’s the underrated anthem for anyone who has ever had a messy, unforgettable love.
#6: “King of My Heart” (Reputation) – The Anthem That Got Buried
It’s time for a Reputation appreciation moment. Yes, the album was filled with bangers like “Look What You Made Me Do,” but “King of My Heart” is that one song that blends synth-pop with pure romantic vibes. It’s the kind of song you blast when you’ve finally found the one. And let’s not forget the live version—absolute chills. So, why didn’t it become a fan favorite? It’s a mystery even the Swiftie detectives can’t solve.
#7: “This Love” (1989) – The Most Hauntingly Beautiful Song You Forgot About
Sometimes, Taylor goes full poet on us, and “This Love” is the perfect example. It’s all about the quiet, ethereal kind of love that fades in and out like the tide. “This love is good, this love is bad, this love is alive back from the dead.” Those lyrics? Pure magic. It’s one of those songs that you put on during a rainy day and just… feel. Yet, somehow it got lost in the shuffle of 1989’s mega-hits.
#8: “Afterglow” (Lover) – Apologies Have Never Sounded This Good
We’ve all messed up in relationships, right? “Afterglow” captures that heart-wrenching moment when you realize you were wrong and try to make things right. It’s vulnerable and raw, a classic Taylor Swift move. Yet, it often gets overshadowed by other songs on Lover. If you’re looking for a song that’s perfect for those late-night drives when you’re lost in your thoughts, this is the track that hits just right.
#9: “Sad Beautiful Tragic” (Red) – Because Sad Songs Hit Different
It’s all in the name—“Sad Beautiful Tragic” from Red is a melancholy masterpiece. The song paints a vivid picture of a love that’s fallen apart, with lyrics like “Words, how little they mean, when they’re a little too late.” We know Red has heavy hitters like “All Too Well,” but “Sad Beautiful Tragic” is the slow burn that deserved a lot more love. It’s like reading a heartbroken letter in musical form.
#10: “It’s Time to Go” (Evermore) – The Song for When You Need to Move On
We all know Taylor has mastered the art of the breakup song, but “It’s Time to Go” hits differently. It’s that subtle, empowering push to let go of what’s not meant for you, with poetic lines like “Sometimes giving up is the strong thing.” It’s one of those hidden gems on Evermore that might just give you the strength to move on from that toxic job, relationship, or friendship. It’s the anthem you didn’t know you needed.
So, What’s YOUR Most Underrated Taylor Swift Song?
Got a track that deserves way more love? Did I miss one of your faves? Let’s keep the Swiftie love going in the comments below! Drop your choice and tell us why it should be the next fan-favorite. You might just convince a fellow Swiftie to give it a listen!
And don’t forget—share this with your Taylor-loving bestie who needs to give these tracks another spin. Let’s give these underrated gems the love they deserve. Happy listening!
Bonus Pro Tip: If you’re planning your own Taylor Swift listening party, make sure these songs are on the playlist. Your friends will thank you later.
Now, over to you! What’s your favorite Taylor deep cut? Drop it in the comments!